Beijing, China — A fresh confrontation between China and the Philippines erupted at Scarborough Shoal on Tuesday, after the Chinese coastguard fired water cannons at Philippine vessels and accused them of staging an “illegal intrusion” into disputed waters in the South China Sea. Manila has rejected the claims as “propaganda,” further intensifying tensions over one of Asia’s most contested maritime features.
Chinese Coastguard’s Account
According to Gan Yu, spokesperson for China’s coastguard, more than 10 Philippine vessels entered the waters around Scarborough Shoal from “different directions,” disregarding warnings from Chinese patrol ships. Gan alleged that one Philippine coastguard vessel deliberately rammed a Chinese vessel, damaging its deck railing.
RELATED NEWS : Australia and Papua New Guinea to sign defense pact as China’s influence grows
“The China coastguard lawfully implemented control measures against the Philippine ships,” Gan said in a statement, citing route restrictions, verbal warnings, and the spraying of water cannons. Beijing later released video footage showing a Philippine vessel’s bow making contact with a Chinese ship while being targeted by water jets.
Manila’s Response
The Philippines quickly dismissed China’s version of events. A spokesperson for the Philippine Maritime Council said the Chinese coastguard statement contained “no truth,” describing it as “another case of Chinese disinformation and propaganda.” Officials in Manila insisted that the Philippine ships were operating lawfully within the country’s exclusive economic zone (EEZ).
A Disputed Maritime Hotspot
Scarborough Shoal, known in China as Huangyan Island and in the Philippines as Panatag Shoal, is a 150-square-kilometre chain of reefs and rocks located about 200 kilometres off the Philippine coast. Under international law, the shoal lies within the Philippines’ EEZ, but China has asserted sweeping claims over the area, citing historical grounds.
The shoal is valued for its rich fishing grounds and a turquoise lagoon that provides natural shelter for vessels during storms. Since a 2012 standoff, China has maintained effective control over access to the atoll, blocking Philippine fishing boats and patrols despite a 2016 international tribunal ruling in The Hague that dismissed Beijing’s expansive claims in the South China Sea.
China’s New Nature Reserve
The latest clash comes just days after Beijing announced the creation of a 3,524-hectare national nature reserve covering the northeastern section of Scarborough Shoal, an area close to its only navigable entrance. China said the reserve would help preserve coral reef ecosystems, but Manila and several analysts view it as a strategic move to reinforce Beijing’s territorial grip.
Security expert Jennifer Parker said last week that the “nature reserve” designation was likely intended to push Filipino vessels further out of the shoal, giving China greater control under the guise of environmental protection.
Strategic and Diplomatic Implications
Scarborough Shoal has become a flashpoint in the wider rivalry between China, the Philippines, and their allies. The United States, which has a mutual defence treaty with Manila, has repeatedly warned Beijing that an armed attack on Philippine public vessels in the South China Sea would trigger its obligations under the treaty.
Despite simmering tensions, no incidents at the shoal have escalated into armed conflict. However, the latest clash highlights the risks of miscalculation as both sides harden their positions.
Beijing insists its actions are lawful and defensive, while Manila accuses China of repeated harassment and violation of international maritime law. The competing narratives reflect a broader struggle over sovereignty, maritime rights, and influence in one of the world’s most strategically significant waterways.
SOURCE : ABC NEWS | Follow Us: Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | Youtube |
